Key lime pie is the official dessert of the City of Key West and it's no wonder why. This creamy, slightly sour treat is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. If you're looking for the best places to enjoy Key West's famous key lime pie, then look no further. Here are some of the top restaurants in Key West that serve up delicious key lime pies.
The Blue Heaven restaurant is a must-stop on your trip with their perfect key lime pie. It's one of the best restaurants in the city and their key lime pie is topped with whipped cream. The Old Town Bakery prepares old-fashioned, artisanal key lime tarts in Key West, brimming with the charm of old Florida. You'll have a hard time not wanting to take a piece home as a souvenir, topped with fresh, home-grown whipped cream immediately before serving. Pepe's Cafe, a former key lime pie bakery in Key West dating back to 1909, is the oldest restaurant in the area.
They've been selling local delicacies for over a century and their key lime pie is a big competitor to Mrs. Mac's Kitchen, which also sells delicious key lime pies. The candies are handmade from scratch, including some of the most incredible traditional key lime tarts. You'll never find any of these pastries in grocery stores or online. This includes delicious key lime tarts, peanut butter mousse cake, peanut butter perversion, carrot tarts, small citrus fruits, and other treats.
You can enjoy the cake combined with an additional cost from a Cuban coffee queen. Pepe's Cafe now serves some of the most incredible traditional key lime tarts out there, along with its most popular dishes. The dough is made of cookies, sugar, and butter; it's filled with a mixture of eggs, condensed milk, and lime juice; and it's topped with whipped cream. Kermit's Key Lime Pie is one of the best Key Largo cakes in South Florida and has a friendly staff. Kermit's offers the traditional key lime pie with Graham cracker dough and whipped cream topping.
You can buy the whole cake or eat a slice of key lime pie. Also available are the best key lime pie bar (famous in Key West and ideal to take away), the chocolate-dipped key lime pie, and the gluten-free key lime pie. The filling is made from small limes (whose skin is yellow when ripe) that are only found in the Florida Keys. The pie filling contains eggs, condensed milk, coconut flan and lime juice. A traditional key lime pie uses Graham cracker dough with whipped cream topping.
It can be served frozen or cold, but it's best when served cold. The Thai Island Lime Pie is a delicious version of a classic Florida dessert. The sauce and whipped topping add a touch of coconut flavor, making it creamy, spicy, and sweet. You'll enjoy a happy hour when your taste buds try this cake. The restaurant with outdoor patio at the Key West Marriott Beachside Hotel is on the third floor and has beautiful ocean views. The Key Lime Pie has a delicious coconut crust and juicy berries, and you can also enjoy their live music.
Their key lime pie is perfect for any nighttime event and special occasion.